Forum › Former Evil General Is Crushing on the Magical Girl discussion

Img_8467
joined Jun 30, 2025

Talking about the book, you mean manga right? Or is there a light novel coming?

Img_0057
joined Jan 2, 2021

You know, some writers would really benefit from a person who can look at their work and just tell them no sometimes. (Like an editor.)

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

My only hope is the lord is not the actual older magical girl she liked

Why are we so sure Junna is not the magic girl? She has the charm, right? Even though she claims she's not the magic girl, we know for a fact that Junna's memory is spotty at best so we can't take her word for it.

last edited at Oct 12, 2026 7:32PM

joined Aug 11, 2022

Also something no one has mentioned is that it seems that "Gonna die a brutal death at Junna's hands" person mentioned that their Lord's body is gone and can be brought back with a vessel.

Looks at my previous comment before your comment about how evil big boss can possibly be revived by possessing another powerful magical girl body

Eh...It fine I am used to be being ignored, it my superpower lol XD

My only hope is the lord is not the actual older magical girl she liked

Why are we so sure Junna is not the magic girl? She has the charm, right? Even though she claims she's not the magic >girl, we know for a fact that Junna's memory is spotty at best so we can't take her word for it.

We just have strong evidence...Just not 100% percentage sure...I was initially banking hard on the theory and idea but then other people began to doubt it claiming their ages don't match or something and you know author can suddenly change the story-mid way and makes the older purple magical girl not be Juuna (Red herring trope)

Basically we have strong evidence and guesses but no one is willing to confirm their guesses basically?

Also...Assuming the case of Junna not being the older purple magical girl...Then the only way the big evil boss lord being the purple hair magical girl is if they killed her and used her body to revive their old boss (Hane and her team + the other possible magical girls already defeated the boss according to this chapter. So seems very unlikely the purple hair magical girl is the lord/evil boss...Since the evil boss is dead and I am assuming Hane has help fight the lord at the time.)

xxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxx
(For this chapter further comments.)

Also this chapter is actually canon according to the comment I read...?! Seriously?!....That is fked up...Hane 'Don't look" comment to Junna is pure classic NTR like...Hopefully the other magical girls besides the trio managed to step in and save them before anything bad and serious could have happen (I am assuming there is more magical girls than just the trio consisting of Lemon, Hane, and Sou since from previous chapter I had noticed dialog telling Hane to hurry up since their boss is defenseless, Chapter 15 specifically. Chapter 15 is the reason why I believe Junna is not their organization only general and why I think there is like 2 to 3 more general level that are similar level but not more powerful than Junna. Basically it was a huge attack on the evil side by both the trio plus other magical girls joining forces).

If this happen in the past...Why is Junna not covered in blood (Assuming she de transformed...Must be some powerful healing by Hane and I guess her normal clothes were safe from getting splash in all the blood... + Then I guess there is also the factor of defeating the big evil boss of the organization....Basically Hane using powerful healing spell magic to revive Junna+ defeating any other minions that drains their MP and stamina + using their stamina, HP + MP for the big boss fight === Basically at 1% MP and HP at the time of getting a surprise attack then it like the comparison of getting sudden Gary oak battle encounter without any having any pokemon at full HP or TP moves...Basically a unfair condition where Hane was basically at her 2nd evolution state instead of her gem full wing state due to healing Junna + using too much magical energy for the big boss fight. This is all of course assuming that everything that happen is canon and true instead of a bad dream/bad end alternative route for Junna 0_0. Basically if this is canon and true event then this must have happen just a hour or two after defeating the big boss fight or just a single day at most after defeating the big boss fight when Hane and her teammates were still recovering their HP & MP= unable to fight at 100%. Basically Hane was struck back in her gem evolution form just below her full wing form magical girl form= not her full power form basically. Level 1, level 2 and level 3 (Final wing gem heart form which Hane wasn't at in chapter 26 like other people had point out earlier???).)

Though that might be just a very rare visual error perhaps just like chapter 6 page 1 (Hane should be gem wing form)???? But she has a gem wing form in chapter 6 and page 3. Or even the small visual error mistake like on chapter 9 page 2 (Non-wing gem heart form) but returning to show full wing gem heart (Likely author just had hard time and didn't want to make the small wing details on Hane on page 2 on chapter 9 to save time since it shows gem heart wings on page 1 of ch.9)

Smug
joined Dec 16, 2015

oops. Sorry RandomFanZ.

Btw the creator does have a Booth page, and hopefully it will have whatever book they will be selling at Winter Comiket as well, when it releases.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

We just have strong evidence...Just not 100% percentage sure...I was initially banking hard on the theory and idea but then other people began to doubt it claiming their ages don't match or something and you know author can suddenly change the story-mid way and makes the older purple magical girl not be Juuna (Red herring trope)

I see some people insisting Junna's not the magical girl but not a single one of them has a good explanation as to why Junna has the charm. If anything, the charm is the strongest most solid evidence we have on the matter, and it points to Junna being the magical girl. Heck, in this chapter the charm started to glow as if it was responding to Junna's feelings.

Enanano
joined Oct 16, 2020

purple guy oughta die

joined Jun 10, 2023

Considering that I doubt most of us will make it to winter Comiket in person, I'm hoping that info on how to get the book will be forthcoming.

It will most likely be available to buy online at BOOTH or melonbooks. You can use a proxy service to buy it on your behalf and ship it to wherever you live

Screenshot_2020-10-28_003849_2_2_69
joined Sep 14, 2014

please link and news blast when the book goes on sale so i can buy all the books from this series

Hj
joined May 3, 2020

I feel violated. This went to a very dark and entirely unnecessary place.

joined Jan 8, 2025

Hopefully the other magical girls besides the trio managed to step in and save them before anything bad and serious could have happen

I feel like some people are overlooking what is being clearly signposted as the outcome here. So just to quick recap the important bits of the last two chapters

Junna is thought to be powerless by the magical girls
Last chapter it was revealed that at some point Junna had regained powers, but with a form different from when she was a General
It was also revealed that Junna has developed a fixation on Hane and the idea that she has to kill Hane so no one else can intrude on Hane last's moments
This chapter someone manages to beat the magical girls and starts describing a fate for Hane that Junna finds utterly unacceptable
Junna's special charm starts glowing with magical power

Take all that together and it seems pretty clear that this is the moment that Junna develops her new form and uses it to curbstomp this other general guy. But it is also where she develops the idea that she has to kill Hane herself. Cause as much as Junna loves Hane and want to be with her, even as a replacement for that 'other' girl, she'd rather abandon that dream and ensure Hane is given a proper end than risk the chance of Hane being subjected to a wretched fate

joined Sep 25, 2017

Take all that together and it seems pretty clear that this is the moment that Junna develops her new form and uses it to curbstomp this other general guy. But it is also where she develops the idea that she has to kill Hane herself. Cause as much as Junna loves Hane and want to be with her, even as a replacement for that 'other' girl, she'd rather abandon that dream and ensure Hane is given a proper end than risk the chance of Hane being subjected to a wretched fate

That actually makes so much sense!!

Standalone%20kurarin
joined Dec 1, 2010

[Ch26] I live the flowers as gore/blood metaphor. It's more genius and elegant and pretty every time it comes up. Flower petals leaking from Junna's hands as she digs her nails into her palm was just chef's kiss.

Kinda bummed the artist wasn't excited that their comic was exposed to another audience, even though it wasn't with their permission. When artists react negatively to reposts and translations it makes me feel bad for enjoying and liking them, like I did something I wasn't supposed to.

Internet_lied
joined Jul 15, 2016

Kinda bummed the artist wasn't excited that their comic was exposed to another audience, even though it wasn't with their permission. When artists react negatively to reposts and translations it makes me feel bad for enjoying and liking them, like I did something I wasn't supposed to.

From what I know, most doujin creators write for the domestic market, first and foremost. When a particular work breaks "containment" and becomes popular overseas, its authors often don't know how to react to it -- hence an initial lack of excitement.

Kokoko
joined Mar 14, 2014

How unlikely is it that the purple magical girl is Junna from the future with time magic? Huh, Homura? I don't who you're talking about.

Kohaku%20avatar%20500px
joined Jul 10, 2016

This while goddamn thing is cut up worse than Memento.

Still love it though.

rudtud Uploader
Soga Lisa Staff
Bsegckseb1dasaousgh17znf
Soga Scans
joined May 29, 2022

Maybe the real Former Evil General was the Crush on the Magical Girl all along

emberisthesilliest
Img_6941
joined Feb 24, 2026

How unlikely is it that the purple magical girl is Junna from the future with time magic? Huh, Homura? I don't who you're talking about.

wait thats a good theory

To reply you must either login or sign up.